/Estimator/ Interview Questions
SENIOR LEVEL

Can you give an example of a project where there were discrepancies between the estimated and actual costs? How did you analyze and determine the reason for these discrepancies?

Estimator Interview Questions
Can you give an example of a project where there were discrepancies between the estimated and actual costs? How did you analyze and determine the reason for these discrepancies?

Sample answer to the question

Yes, I can give an example of a project where there were discrepancies between the estimated and actual costs. In a previous construction project, we estimated the cost of materials and labor to be $500,000 based on the project plans and specifications. However, during the construction phase, we encountered unexpected delays, which resulted in increased labor costs and extended project duration. Additionally, there were changes in the design that required additional materials and skilled labor. As a Senior Estimator, I analyzed the project documents, tracked the actual costs incurred, and compared them to the estimated costs. I found that the discrepancies were primarily due to the changes in design and the unforeseen delays. To determine the reasons for these discrepancies, I held discussions with the project team, contractors, and suppliers. We reviewed the project timeline, assessed the impact of design changes, and identified areas where the estimation could be improved in the future. This analysis helped us identify the factors that contributed to the cost discrepancies and enabled us to make recommendations for improving the estimation process.

A more solid answer

Certainly! Let me share an example of a construction project I worked on where there were discrepancies between the estimated and actual costs. We were tasked with building a commercial office space, and based on the project plans and specifications, the estimated cost was $2.5 million. However, during the construction phase, we encountered several unforeseen challenges. Firstly, we discovered that the soil conditions were unstable, requiring additional foundation work and soil stabilization measures. This led to increased costs for both materials and labor. Secondly, there were design changes requested by the client, which impacted the overall project scope and required modifications to the initial estimates. These changes included installing high-end finishes and incorporating energy-efficient systems, which added to the overall cost. As a Senior Estimator, I took a proactive approach to analyzing these discrepancies. I closely monitored the progress of the project, tracked the actual costs incurred, and compared them to the estimated costs on a regular basis. I collaborated with the project team, including architects, engineers, and contractors, to identify the reasons behind the discrepancies. We conducted thorough reviews of the project documents, such as architectural and engineering drawings, to ensure accurate estimation. Additionally, I leveraged my strong analytical and problem-solving skills to identify areas where the estimation process could be improved. By evaluating the discrepancies, I found that a lack of detailed analysis during the initial estimation phase contributed to the cost variations. To address this, I proposed implementing a more comprehensive risk assessment and contingency planning process during the estimation stage. This would help account for potential unforeseen challenges and reduce discrepancies between estimated and actual costs. Overall, my ability to analyze and determine the reasons for discrepancies was essential in mitigating potential risks and ensuring more accurate cost estimates for future projects.

Why this is a more solid answer:

The solid answer expands on the basic answer by providing a detailed example of a construction project with cost discrepancies. It addresses the evaluation areas mentioned in the job description, such as construction estimating, reading architectural and engineering drawings, analytical skills, and communication abilities. The answer also includes specific details about the challenges faced during the project, the analysis process, and recommendations for improvement. However, it can be further improved by incorporating more information on cost analysis techniques and the impact of the discrepancies on the project's overall success.

An exceptional answer

Absolutely! Let me share a comprehensive example of a project where discrepancies between the estimated and actual costs occurred. In a high-rise residential construction project, the initial estimated cost was $20 million, based on detailed construction plans and specifications. However, during the execution phase, we encountered multiple factors that led to significant cost variations. Firstly, an unexpected increase in material prices occurred due to global market fluctuations, resulting in higher procurement costs. Secondly, changes in local regulations required implementing additional safety measures, including advanced fire detection systems and enhanced structural reinforcements. These changes significantly impacted the overall cost. Moreover, the project schedule faced delays due to adverse weather conditions, causing a ripple effect on labor costs and extended project duration. As the Senior Estimator, I played a crucial role in analyzing these discrepancies. I employed advanced cost analysis techniques, such as earned value analysis and variance analysis, to assess the reasons behind the cost variations. Through rigorous data collection and tracking, I identified the specific factors contributing to the discrepancies and their monetary impact on the project. Additionally, I collaborated closely with the project team and engaged in regular communication with contractors and suppliers to gather real-time cost data and insights. This information allowed me to conduct a thorough root cause analysis and propose effective solutions. To prevent similar discrepancies in the future, I recommended enhancing the estimation process by incorporating risk assessments and contingency planning at a granular level. This would involve considering market dynamics, regulatory changes, and weather conditions during the initial estimation phase. Moreover, I suggested establishing strong vendor relationships to ensure accurate pricing information and conducting regular cost reviews throughout the project lifecycle. By implementing these improvements, we would demonstrate a proactive approach to cost management and minimize discrepancies between estimated and actual costs. The ability to analyze and determine the reasons for discrepancies is crucial in maintaining project profitability and ensuring successful outcomes.

Why this is an exceptional answer:

The exceptional answer provides a detailed and comprehensive example of a project with cost discrepancies. It addresses all the evaluation areas mentioned in the job description, showcasing advanced skills in construction estimating, interpretation of architectural and engineering drawings, strong analytical, organizational, and problem-solving skills, as well as excellent communication and negotiation abilities. The answer includes specific details about the various factors contributing to the cost discrepancies, the cost analysis techniques employed, and recommendations for improvement. It demonstrates a thorough understanding of cost management and risk assessment in construction projects. The answer also highlights the impact of the discrepancies on the project's overall success and profitability.

How to prepare for this question

  • Familiarize yourself with industry-standard estimation software such as Timberline or ProEst, as proficiency in these tools is highly valued in the role of an Estimator.
  • Prioritize accuracy and attention to detail in your previous cost estimation experiences. Providing examples of how you ensured precise estimations and mitigated discrepancies will showcase your ability to perform in this role.
  • Demonstrate your analytical and problem-solving skills by discussing projects where you analyzed cost discrepancies and determined the reasons behind them. Talk about the specific techniques or methodologies you used to conduct such analysis.
  • Highlight your ability to collaborate and communicate with various stakeholders, including architects, engineers, contractors, and vendors. Effective communication in discussing and resolving cost discrepancies is crucial for success in this role.
  • Prepare examples of improvements you have suggested or implemented to minimize discrepancies between estimated and actual costs. This could include recommendations for enhanced risk assessment, contingency planning, or improved vendor relationships.

What interviewers are evaluating

  • Advanced skills in construction estimating and cost analysis.
  • Ability to read and interpret architectural and engineering drawings.
  • Strong analytical, organizational, and problem-solving skills.
  • Excellent communication and negotiation abilities.

Related Interview Questions

More questions for Estimator interviews