Tell me about a time when you had to make a difficult ethical decision in your practice. How did you approach the situation?

JUNIOR LEVEL
Tell me about a time when you had to make a difficult ethical decision in your practice. How did you approach the situation?
Sample answer to the question:
One time when I had to make a difficult ethical decision in my practice was when a patient with a history of substance abuse came to me seeking pain medication. I knew that prescribing opioids to this patient could potentially enable their addiction and pose a risk to their health. I approached the situation by first gathering all the necessary information about the patient's medical history and past treatments. I then consulted with my colleagues and a pain management specialist to explore alternative pain management options that would be less addictive. Together, we developed a comprehensive treatment plan that included non-opioid pain medications, physical therapy, and counseling. Although it was a challenging decision, I prioritized the well-being of the patient and their long-term recovery.
Here is a more solid answer:
In my practice, I encountered a difficult ethical decision when a patient presented with a complex condition that required a surgical procedure. However, the patient had a high risk of complications due to their pre-existing medical conditions. I approached the situation by thoroughly reviewing the patient's medical history, consulting with other specialists, and considering the potential benefits and risks of the surgery. I also engaged in open and transparent communication with the patient, ensuring they fully understood the potential outcomes and risks involved. After a series of discussions and consultations, we collectively decided that the surgery was not the best option for the patient's overall well-being. Instead, we explored alternative treatment plans and engaged in a comprehensive care approach that focused on managing the symptoms and improving the patient's quality of life.
Why is this a more solid answer?
The solid answer provides more specific details about the candidate's approach to the ethical decision-making process. It mentions thorough review of medical history, consultations with specialists, and open communication with the patient. The candidate also highlights the consideration of alternative treatment plans and a comprehensive care approach. However, the answer could still be improved by including the specific ethical aspects of the decision and the outcome of the chosen alternative treatment plan.
An example of a exceptional answer:
A notable ethical decision I encountered in my practice involved a patient who required a limb amputation due to a life-threatening infection. However, the patient expressed significant emotional distress and resistance towards the procedure, as they believed that losing the limb would severely impact their quality of life. In approaching this situation, I recognized the importance of empathy and collaboration. I engaged in extensive discussions with the patient, their family, and a multi-disciplinary team of healthcare professionals, including psychologists and rehabilitation specialists. Together, we explored all possible treatment options, including aggressive antibiotic therapy and innovative wound care techniques. I ensured the patient's autonomy was respected throughout the decision-making process, providing them with comprehensive information on the potential risks and benefits of each option. Ultimately, we reached a consensus that the risk of a life-threatening infection outweighed the potential loss of limb function, and the patient underwent the amputation surgery. Through this difficult ethical decision, I learned the significance of patient-centered care and fostering a supportive environment to empower patients in decision-making.
Why is this an exceptional answer?
The exceptional answer provides a detailed and comprehensive account of the candidate's approach to the difficult ethical decision. It demonstrates excellent critical thinking skills, quick decision-making, and strong communication abilities. The candidate emphasizes empathy, collaboration, and patient-centered care throughout the decision-making process. The answer also highlights the consideration of alternative treatment options and the final outcome of the decision. Overall, it showcases the candidate's ability to handle complex ethical dilemmas in a compassionate and informed manner.
How to prepare for this question:
  • Reflect on past experiences where ethical decisions were required and the thought process behind them. Consider ethical dilemmas specific to the field of adult reconstructive orthopedics.
  • Familiarize yourself with the principles of medical ethics, such as autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice.
  • Stay updated on relevant guidelines, protocols, and best practices related to ethical decision-making in orthopedic surgery.
  • Practice discussing ethical scenarios with colleagues or mentors to refine your ability to articulate your decision-making process.
  • Be prepared to provide examples that showcase your strong communication skills, critical thinking abilities, and commitment to patient well-being.
What are interviewers evaluating with this question?
  • Critical thinking skills
  • Ability to make quick decisions
  • Strong communication skills

Want content like this in your inbox?
Sign Up for our Newsletter

By clicking "Sign up" you consent and agree to Jobya's Terms & Privacy policies

Related Interview Questions