How do you handle situations where you disagree with the treatment plan or decisions made by other healthcare professionals?

JUNIOR LEVEL
How do you handle situations where you disagree with the treatment plan or decisions made by other healthcare professionals?
Sample answer to the question:
When I disagree with the treatment plan or decisions made by other healthcare professionals, I believe in open and respectful communication. I would first seek to understand their perspective and rationale behind their decisions. I would then share my concerns and provide any evidence-based information or alternative options that I believe could improve the patient's care. I would do this in a professional and collaborative manner, focusing on the best interest of the patient. Ultimately, if we are unable to reach a consensus, I would escalate the issue to the appropriate supervisor or team lead.
Here is a more solid answer:
When I disagree with the treatment plan or decisions made by other healthcare professionals, I take a collaborative approach to resolve the issue. I start by actively listening to their perspective and asking questions to understand their reasoning. Then, I share my concerns and provide evidence-based information to support my viewpoint. I believe in maintaining a respectful and professional tone throughout the discussion, focusing on the best interest of the patient. If we are unable to reach a consensus, I would involve other members of the healthcare team or escalate the issue to the appropriate supervisor or manager.
Why is this a more solid answer?
The solid answer provides a more detailed and comprehensive response. It demonstrates the candidate's ability to actively listen, ask questions, and provide evidence-based information. The candidate also emphasizes the importance of maintaining a respectful and professional tone during discussions. The answer aligns well with the job requirements, particularly in terms of clinical judgment, teamwork, and communication skills. However, it could benefit from providing specific examples to further illustrate the candidate's experience in handling disagreements.
An example of a exceptional answer:
In situations where I disagree with the treatment plan or decisions made by other healthcare professionals, I follow a systematic approach to address the issue. First, I seek to fully understand their perspective by asking open-ended questions and actively listening. I then conduct a thorough review of the available evidence and guidelines to support my viewpoint. When discussing my concerns, I use a collaborative and diplomatic approach, highlighting the potential impact on patient outcomes. Additionally, I propose alternative options that align with best practices and patient preferences. If a resolution cannot be reached, I escalate the issue to the appropriate channels while maintaining professionalism and respect. For example, I once encountered a disagreement regarding the dosage of a medication for a patient. I engaged in discussions with the prescribing physician, presenting relevant research articles and sharing my clinical judgment. After considering my input, the physician agreed to modify the dosage, resulting in improved patient outcomes.
Why is this an exceptional answer?
The exceptional answer goes above and beyond by providing a systematic approach to addressing disagreements and incorporating a personal example to showcase the candidate's experience and skills. The candidate demonstrates strong critical thinking skills, evidence-based practice, and effective communication strategies. The answer establishes the candidate as a confident and assertive professional who maintains a focus on patient outcomes. It aligns well with the job requirements, particularly in terms of clinical judgment, teamwork, and communication. However, the answer could be further improved by highlighting the candidate's ability to adapt to high-stress environments and manage multiple patient care priorities simultaneously.
How to prepare for this question:
  • Familiarize yourself with evidence-based guidelines and research relevant to your specialty area.
  • Practice active listening and asking open-ended questions to understand others' perspectives.
  • Develop skills in presenting your concerns and supporting arguments in a diplomatic and persuasive manner.
  • Reflect on past experiences where you had disagreements with colleagues or healthcare professionals and think about how you handled those situations.
  • Consider seeking guidance from a mentor or experienced healthcare professional to further develop your approach to handling disagreements.
What are interviewers evaluating with this question?
  • Clinical judgment and decision-making
  • Ability to work as part of a team
  • Communication and interpersonal skills

Want content like this in your inbox?
Sign Up for our Newsletter

By clicking "Sign up" you consent and agree to Jobya's Terms & Privacy policies

Related Interview Questions