Have you ever encountered a patient who disagreed with your treatment plan? How did you handle the situation?

JUNIOR LEVEL
Have you ever encountered a patient who disagreed with your treatment plan? How did you handle the situation?
Sample answer to the question:
Yes, I have encountered a patient who disagreed with my treatment plan. It was a patient with a complex heart condition who had been receiving a particular medication for a long time. However, based on the latest research and best practices, I believed that a different medication would be more effective for their condition. I explained my rationale to the patient, highlighting the potential benefits and addressing any concerns they had. Despite my efforts, the patient was still hesitant to change their medication. In such situations, I believe in a patient-centered approach, so I respected their decision and continued to monitor their condition closely. I ensured that they understood the risks and potential consequences of their choice, while also providing ongoing education about alternative treatment options. Ultimately, my goal is to establish a collaborative relationship with patients, where we work together to make informed decisions about their care.
Here is a more solid answer:
Yes, in my experience as a Cardiology Nurse Practitioner, I have encountered a patient who disagreed with my treatment plan. The patient had a history of heart failure and was prescribed a specific medication by another healthcare provider. However, after reviewing their medical history and conducting further research, I believed that a different medication would be more appropriate for their condition. I approached the patient with empathy and listened to their concerns about changing their medication. To address their reservations, I sought a second opinion from a senior cardiologist to validate my treatment plan. Additionally, I involved the patient's family in the discussion to ensure their support and understanding. We had an open and honest conversation, discussing the potential benefits and risks of the proposed treatment change. Ultimately, we came to a mutual agreement, and the patient agreed to try the new medication for a trial period. Throughout the process, I provided continuous education and support to the patient and their family to ensure they felt empowered and informed about their treatment decisions.
Why is this a more solid answer?
The solid answer provides specific details about how the candidate handled the situation. It mentions seeking a second opinion and involving the patient's family in the decision-making process, which showcases their commitment to thoroughness and collaborative decision-making. However, it could be further improved by discussing any alternative solutions explored and addressing potential challenges faced during the process.
An example of a exceptional answer:
Yes, as a Cardiology Nurse Practitioner, I encountered a patient who disagreed with my treatment plan. The patient had a history of atrial fibrillation and was currently on a specific anti-coagulation medication. However, based on the latest clinical guidelines and emerging evidence, I believed that switching to a novel oral anticoagulant would be more beneficial in terms of reducing the risk of stroke and bleeding complications. Understanding the importance of clear communication, I scheduled a dedicated appointment with the patient to discuss the proposed treatment change. During the appointment, I presented the patient with evidence-based research articles and visual aids to educate them on the newer medication's advantages. I also emphasized that shared decision-making is crucial in their care journey. To ensure the patient had all the necessary information, I provided them with an information pamphlet that summarized the key points discussed during our meeting. Recognizing the significance of a collaborative approach, I involved the patient's primary care physician and a senior cardiologist in the decision-making process. We held a multidisciplinary meeting, where we discussed the patient's medical history, treatment options, risks, and benefits. Together, we executed a shared decision-making plan, weighing the patient's preferences and unique circumstances. I continued to monitor the patient closely and conducted regular follow-up appointments to evaluate their response to the new medication. By involving the patient in the decision-making process and providing a thorough explanation of the rationale, I was able to build trust and maintain a strong therapeutic relationship with the patient.
Why is this an exceptional answer?
The exceptional answer demonstrates a high level of expertise and comprehensive approach in handling the situation. It includes specific details about the patient's condition, discusses the utilization of evidence-based research and visual aids to educate the patient, involves the patient's primary care physician and a senior cardiologist in the decision-making process, and highlights the importance of ongoing monitoring and follow-up appointments. This answer showcases the candidate's strong clinical skills, excellent communication, and ability to work collaboratively in a multidisciplinary team.
How to prepare for this question:
  • Familiarize yourself with the latest clinical guidelines and emerging evidence in cardiology.
  • Practice clear and concise communication to effectively explain treatment plans to patients.
  • Develop skills in shared decision-making and involving patients in their care journey.
  • Be prepared to seek second opinions and involve other healthcare professionals in the decision-making process.
  • Stay updated on alternative treatment options and their potential benefits and risks.
What are interviewers evaluating with this question?
  • Interpersonal skills
  • Decision-making
  • Problem-solving

Want content like this in your inbox?
Sign Up for our Newsletter

By clicking "Sign up" you consent and agree to Jobya's Terms & Privacy policies

Related Interview Questions