/Underwriting Manager/ Interview Questions
SENIOR LEVEL

Tell me about a time when you faced a challenging negotiation in the underwriting process.

Underwriting Manager Interview Questions
Tell me about a time when you faced a challenging negotiation in the underwriting process.

Sample answer to the question

During my time as an underwriter, I faced a challenging negotiation in the underwriting process when reviewing a complex application for a commercial loan. The applicant had a high credit score but lacked sufficient collateral to secure the loan. As a result, I had to negotiate with the applicant to find alternative ways to mitigate the risk and protect the company's interests. After discussing various options, we agreed to adjust the loan terms and incorporate additional guarantees from the applicant's business partners. This negotiation required careful communication and persuasion skills to find a mutually beneficial solution. In the end, we were able to approve the loan with added protection and ensure the company's risk was minimized.

A more solid answer

During my time as an Underwriting Manager, I encountered a challenging negotiation in the underwriting process when reviewing an application for a complex commercial property insurance policy. The policyholder wanted to reduce the premiums significantly without compromising coverage, posing a potential risk for the company. To address this, I utilized my technical knowledge of underwriting software and systems to thoroughly analyze the policy and identify areas where we could make adjustments to meet the client's needs while managing our risk exposure effectively. I then engaged in open and transparent communication with the policyholder, explaining the necessity of certain premium levels based on the risk assessment. Through active listening and empathy, I understood the policyholder's concerns and worked collaboratively to find a middle ground that satisfied both parties. By leveraging my problem-solving and negotiation skills, I successfully reached a compromise that provided the policyholder with reduced premiums while ensuring adequate coverage and profitability for the company.

Why this is a more solid answer:

The solid answer provides more specific details about the challenging negotiation in the underwriting process, showcasing the candidate's technical knowledge of underwriting software and systems. It also highlights their strong communication and interpersonal skills in handling the negotiation. The answer demonstrates the candidate's problem-solving and negotiation abilities. However, it can still be improved by including more concrete examples or specific outcomes of the negotiation.

An exceptional answer

As an Underwriting Manager, I encountered a challenging negotiation in the underwriting process when dealing with a high-profile client seeking a complex insurance policy for their global manufacturing operations. The client wanted to secure the policy at a significantly lower premium rate than our initial assessment indicated was appropriate. To navigate this negotiation, I utilized my deep technical knowledge of underwriting software and systems to thoroughly analyze the client's risk profile and pinpoint areas where we could offer customized coverage options to reduce their overall premium exposure while still maintaining a profitable arrangement for our company. I engaged in strategic communication with the client's risk management team, emphasizing our commitment to comprehensive risk evaluation while explaining the underlying underwriting principles and industry regulations. By collaborating closely with our underwriting team, we devised a unique risk-sharing strategy that not only addressed the client's concerns but also protected our company's financial interests. The negotiation resulted in a mutually beneficial agreement that included specific policy terms and conditions tailored to the client's needs. This experience showcased my ability to effectively negotiate under high-pressure situations, leverage advanced technical knowledge, and maintain positive relationships with clients, all while adhering to industry best practices and regulatory compliance.

Why this is an exceptional answer:

The exceptional answer provides a more comprehensive response by incorporating specific details about the challenging negotiation in the underwriting process with a high-profile client. It highlights the candidate's deep technical knowledge of underwriting software and systems, as well as their ability to effectively negotiate and maintain positive client relationships. The answer also emphasizes the candidate's strategic thinking and adherence to industry best practices and regulatory compliance. Additionally, the exceptional answer includes concrete examples of the negotiation outcomes and showcases the candidate's ability to tailor policy terms and conditions to the client's needs. This level of detail and complexity elevates the response to an exceptional level.

How to prepare for this question

  • Familiarize yourself with underwriting principles, practices, and regulations to showcase your technical knowledge in negotiations.
  • Highlight your experience in dealing with complex applications or policies to demonstrate your ability to handle challenging negotiations.
  • Practice effective communication and interpersonal skills, especially in explaining underwriting decisions and negotiating terms with clients.
  • Develop problem-solving strategies to address scenarios where parties have conflicting goals and work towards a mutually beneficial solution.
  • Stay updated with industry trends and changes in underwriting software and systems to showcase your adaptability and proficiency.

What interviewers are evaluating

  • Problem-solving and negotiation
  • Communication and interpersonal skills
  • Technical knowledge of underwriting software and systems

Related Interview Questions

More questions for Underwriting Manager interviews