Tell me about a time when you had to make a difficult decision in a research project.
Catalysis Scientist Interview Questions
Sample answer to the question
In a research project I worked on, we were investigating a new catalytic process for the production of a specific chemical compound. During the project, we encountered a technical challenge that required us to make a difficult decision. The challenge was that the desired chemical compound was not being produced efficiently enough and we were running out of time to meet our project deadline. After carefully analyzing the data and conducting additional experiments, we realized that we needed to change the reaction conditions and modify the catalyst composition. Making this decision was difficult because it involved deviating from the original plan and potentially risking the success of the project. However, we ultimately decided to take the risk and make the necessary changes. As a result, we were able to significantly improve the efficiency of the process and meet our project deadline successfully.
A more solid answer
In one of my research projects, I was leading a team tasked with developing a new catalytic process for the conversion of biomass into biofuels. We encountered a major hurdle when the catalyst we were using did not perform as expected, leading to low conversion rates. This was a critical problem as the success of the project depended on achieving high conversion efficiency. To address this issue, I immediately consulted with my team and we brainstormed potential solutions. After careful analysis of the experimental data and extensive literature review, we identified a new catalyst that had shown promising results in similar systems. Making the decision to switch to a new catalyst was not an easy one, as it required significant time and effort to modify our experimental setup. However, we collectively agreed that it was necessary to proceed with the change in order to achieve the desired outcomes. The decision also involved coordinating with our collaborators to ensure a seamless transition. Eventually, the switch proved to be the right decision as we observed a dramatic improvement in the conversion rates. This experience taught me the importance of adaptability and the need to be open to change when faced with unforeseen challenges in research projects.
Why this is a more solid answer:
The solid answer builds upon the basic answer by providing more specific details about the research project and the candidate's expertise in catalysis. It also highlights the candidate's strong problem-solving skills and ability to collaborate with a team to make informed decisions. Additionally, it mentions the candidate's experience in project management by indicating their role as a team leader. However, the answer could be improved by including more information about the candidate's project management skills and the impact of their decision on the overall project timeline and success.
An exceptional answer
During my tenure as a Senior Catalysis Scientist at my previous company, I was leading a high-profile research project focused on developing a novel catalyst for a crucial chemical transformation in the pharmaceutical industry. This project had strict timelines and deliverables that required me to make a difficult decision when we encountered unexpected challenges. We discovered that the performance of our catalyst was inconsistent and did not meet the desired selectivity targets, which posed a significant risk to the project's success. To address this issue, I adopted a systematic approach. First, I thoroughly analyzed the reaction mechanism and conducted extensive literature research to identify potential modifications to improve the catalyst's performance. After reviewing the available options, I decided to explore a new ligand design that had shown promising results in similar catalytic systems. To expedite the process, I initiated collaboration with a leading research group in ligand design. This collaboration allowed us to access their expertise and synthesize the desired ligands quickly. Simultaneously, I revamped the experimental setup by implementing rigorous reaction monitoring techniques using advanced spectroscopy methods. This enabled real-time monitoring of the reaction progress and provided crucial insights into the catalyst's performance. As a result of these strategic decisions, we were able to optimize the catalyst's performance, achieve the desired selectivity, and meet the project timelines. This experience showcased my expertise in catalysis, problem-solving abilities, and effective project management.
Why this is an exceptional answer:
The exceptional answer expands on the solid answer by providing even more specific details about the research project and the candidate's actions taken to address the challenges. It demonstrates the candidate's extensive expertise in catalytic systems and their ability to approach problems systematically. It highlights the candidate's strong project management skills by discussing their collaboration with another research group and their implementation of advanced spectroscopy methods. Additionally, the answer emphasizes the impact of the candidate's decisions on the overall success of the project. Overall, it provides a comprehensive and impressive response to the question.
How to prepare for this question
- Reflect on previous research projects and identify specific difficult decisions you had to make.
- Consider the impact of your decision on the overall project and outcomes.
- Highlight your expertise in catalysis and problem-solving abilities.
- Demonstrate your project management skills by discussing your role in leading research projects and collaborations.
- Practice articulating your decision-making process and the rationale behind your choices.
What interviewers are evaluating
- Expertise in catalysis
- Problem-solving skills
- Project management skills
Related Interview Questions
More questions for Catalysis Scientist interviews