Tell us about a time when you had to make a difficult decision regarding a client's treatment plan. How did you approach it?

INTERMEDIATE LEVEL
Tell us about a time when you had to make a difficult decision regarding a client's treatment plan. How did you approach it?
Sample answer to the question:
I had to make a difficult decision regarding a client's treatment plan when I was working as a telehealth therapist. The client was struggling with severe anxiety and depression, and I had initially recommended CBT (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy) as the main treatment approach. However, after a few sessions, it became evident that the client's symptoms were not improving as expected. I decided to reassess the situation and consult with a colleague to gain a fresh perspective. We conducted a thorough evaluation and realized that the client's underlying trauma was significantly impacting their progress. Based on this new information, I made the difficult decision to transition the treatment plan to include trauma-focused therapy in addition to CBT. While this decision required modifying the treatment plan and adjusting the goals, it ultimately proved to be the right choice. The client started experiencing significant improvements in their mental health, and their symptoms began to subside. I regularly monitored their progress and made further adjustments to optimize their treatment. This experience taught me the importance of being flexible and open to adapting treatment plans when necessary to best meet the client's needs.
Here is a more solid answer:
One instance where I had to make a difficult decision regarding a client's treatment plan was when I was working as a telehealth therapist. The client I was working with had been dealing with chronic insomnia, and I had initially recommended a combination of sleep hygiene practices and cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia (CBT-I). However, after a few sessions, it became apparent that the client's symptoms were not improving as expected, even when they were strictly following the treatment plan. I realized that there may be underlying mental health issues contributing to the insomnia, so I decided to take a step back and reassess the situation. I consulted with a colleague who specialized in anxiety and depression, and we conducted a comprehensive evaluation to gain a deeper understanding of the client's case. Through this evaluation, we discovered that the client had been experiencing significant work-related stress and anxiety, which was fueling their insomnia. Based on this new information, I made the difficult decision to modify the treatment plan to include stress management techniques and relaxation exercises in addition to CBT-I. I explained the reasoning behind the change to the client and ensured their full understanding and consent. Over the next few weeks, we closely monitored the client's progress and made adjustments as needed. Ultimately, this decision proved to be the right one, as the client started experiencing better sleep quality and a reduction in their anxiety levels. This experience taught me the importance of being adaptable and open-minded when it comes to treatment planning, as well as the value of collaborating with colleagues to gain different perspectives and insights.
Why is this a more solid answer?
The solid answer provides a more detailed account of a difficult decision regarding a client's treatment plan. It includes specific details about the client's condition (chronic insomnia), the initial treatment plan (sleep hygiene practices and CBT-I), and the realization that the symptoms were not improving as expected. The answer highlights the approach taken to address the situation, including consulting with a colleague and conducting a comprehensive evaluation. It also explains the decision to modify the treatment plan and the steps taken to monitor the client's progress. The answer demonstrates the candidate's clinical skills, problem-solving abilities, and adaptability. However, it could still benefit from further elaboration on the outcome of the decision and how it positively impacted the client's treatment.
An example of a exceptional answer:
I faced a challenging decision regarding a client's treatment plan during my time as a telehealth therapist. The client I was working with was struggling with bipolar disorder, and we had been utilizing a combination of medication management and psychoeducation to stabilize their mood. However, after a few months, the client's symptoms began to worsen, and they were experiencing frequent mood fluctuations that significantly impacted their daily functioning. Recognizing the urgency of the situation, I immediately collaborated with the client's psychiatrist to discuss potential adjustments to the medication regimen. We conducted a thorough reassessment and reviewed the client's medication history, including previous responses and side effects. Based on our analysis, we made the difficult decision to change the client's medication, transitioning from a standard mood stabilizer to a different medication with proven efficacy in bipolar disorder. I ensured open communication with the client throughout the process, explaining the rationale behind the decision and addressing any concerns or questions they had. Over the following weeks, we closely monitored the client's response to the new medication, making necessary dosage adjustments and addressing any emerging side effects. The client's symptoms gradually began to improve, and after several months, they achieved a more stable mood state that allowed them to engage in daily activities and pursue personal goals. This experience reinforced the importance of collaboration with other healthcare professionals and the need for ongoing evaluation and adjustment in complex cases. It also underscored the significance of effective communication with the client, ensuring their active participation in the decision-making process and fostering a sense of trust and partnership.
Why is this an exceptional answer?
The exceptional answer provides a detailed and comprehensive account of a difficult decision regarding a client's treatment plan. It includes specific details about the client's condition (bipolar disorder), the initial treatment approach (medication management and psychoeducation), and the worsening of symptoms. The answer highlights the candidate's proactive approach in collaborating with the client's psychiatrist and conducting a thorough reassessment. It emphasizes the difficult decision to change the client's medication and the steps taken to monitor and adjust the new medication as needed. The answer also addresses the importance of effective communication with the client and the positive outcome of the decision in stabilizing the client's mood and improving their daily functioning. Overall, the answer demonstrates the candidate's clinical skills, problem-solving abilities, adaptability, and effective collaboration with other healthcare professionals. It covers all the evaluation areas and aligns well with the job description.
How to prepare for this question:
  • Reflect on past experiences where you had to make difficult decisions regarding client treatment plans. Consider situations where you had to think critically, adapt, or collaborate with colleagues.
  • Review your knowledge of different treatment approaches and evidence-based practices in your field. Familiarize yourself with various therapeutic modalities and their applications.
  • Consider the potential challenges that may arise when working as a telehealth therapist and how you would approach them. Think about how you can effectively deliver remote mental health services and maintain client confidentiality in a digital communication environment.
  • Practice explaining difficult decisions you've made in the past and the reasoning behind them. Be prepared to discuss the outcomes of those decisions and how they positively impacted clients.
  • Demonstrate your ability to engage in open communication with clients and collaborate with other healthcare professionals. Highlight instances where you successfully worked as part of a team to optimize client care.
What are interviewers evaluating with this question?
  • Clinical skills
  • Problem-solving
  • Adaptability

Want content like this in your inbox?
Sign Up for our Newsletter

By clicking "Sign up" you consent and agree to Jobya's Terms & Privacy policies

Related Interview Questions