Tell me about a time when you discovered a discrepancy in financial data. What actions did you take?
Finance Manager Interview Questions
Sample answer to the question
In my previous role as a financial analyst, I encountered a discrepancy in the financial data when preparing a monthly financial report. After conducting a thorough review, I discovered that there was an error in the accounts payable balance. To address this, I immediately reached out to the accounts payable team to understand the root cause of the discrepancy. We identified that a vendor invoice had been incorrectly recorded, leading to an overpayment. I worked closely with the team to rectify the error by reconciling the vendor statement and updating the accounts payable records. I also prepared an updated financial report, highlighting the corrected numbers. To prevent similar discrepancies in the future, I suggested implementing additional checks and balances in the accounts payable process, such as regular vendor statement reconciliations and cross-checking invoice amounts. This experience taught me the importance of attention to detail and effective communication when dealing with financial data.
A more solid answer
During my time as a Finance Analyst at XYZ Company, I came across a discrepancy in the financial data while conducting a monthly financial analysis. Upon closer examination, I noticed that the net income for the month was significantly higher than the previous month's records. To investigate further, I collaborated with the accounting team and found that a large revenue transaction had been mistakenly recorded twice, resulting in an inflated net income. Understanding the importance of accuracy in financial reporting, I immediately raised this issue with the senior finance manager and proposed a solution to rectify the error. We decided to adjust the financial statements for the month and issue a corrected version to the stakeholders. Additionally, I conducted a review of the accounting process and recommended implementing an internal control measure, such as a final review of financial statements by a senior team member, to prevent similar discrepancies in the future. This experience highlighted the significance of attention to detail, strong accounting knowledge, and communication skills in addressing financial discrepancies.
Why this is a more solid answer:
The solid answer expands on the basic answer by providing specific and detailed examples of discovering a discrepancy in financial data. It demonstrates the necessary skills and qualifications, such as financial analysis and accounting knowledge, attention to detail, and communication skills. However, it can still be improved by including more information on the actions taken to rectify the discrepancy and prevent future occurrences.
An exceptional answer
As a Finance Manager at ABC Company, I encountered a significant discrepancy in the financial data during the quarterly financial reporting process. While reviewing the balance sheet, I noticed a substantial increase in accounts receivable compared to the previous quarter. Concerned about the accuracy of the data, I initiated a comprehensive investigation. I collaborated with the Accounts Receivable team to analyze individual customer accounts and discovered that a large client payment had been recorded in the wrong period, leading to the inflated accounts receivable balance. To rectify the error, I immediately contacted the client and explained the situation. Working together, we agreed on the appropriate adjustment and revised the payment record accordingly. In addition to resolving the discrepancy, I implemented a rigorous review process for customer payments, which included cross-checking with sales records and regular reconciliation of accounts receivable balances. This experience demonstrated my strong financial analysis skills, attention to detail, problem-solving capabilities, and effective communication with internal and external stakeholders.
Why this is an exceptional answer:
The exceptional answer goes beyond the solid answer by providing a detailed and complex example of discovering a discrepancy in financial data. It showcases the candidate's ability to handle a significant issue and take appropriate actions to rectify it. The answer also highlights additional skills and qualifications required for the Finance Manager role, such as problem-solving capabilities and effective communication with stakeholders. The candidate's ability to implement proactive measures to prevent future discrepancies is also emphasized.
How to prepare for this question
- Familiarize yourself with the financial reporting process and common discrepancies that can occur.
- Highlight any previous experience in financial analysis and accounting during your preparation.
- Practice discussing specific examples of identifying and resolving financial discrepancies, emphasizing the actions taken and the outcomes achieved.
- Demonstrate strong attention to detail and problem-solving skills during the interview by providing detailed and thorough explanations.
- Prepare to discuss your understanding of accounting standards and regulations and how you ensure compliance in your work.
What interviewers are evaluating
- Financial analysis
- Accounting
- Attention to detail
- Communication
Related Interview Questions
More questions for Finance Manager interviews