/Appraisal Reviewer/ Interview Questions
INTERMEDIATE LEVEL

Have you ever encountered a situation where an appraiser was not receptive to your feedback or guidance? How did you handle it?

Appraisal Reviewer Interview Questions
Have you ever encountered a situation where an appraiser was not receptive to your feedback or guidance? How did you handle it?

Sample answer to the question

Yes, I have encountered a situation where an appraiser was not receptive to my feedback or guidance. It was during a review process where I noticed some discrepancies in an appraisal report and I provided constructive feedback to the appraiser. However, the appraiser seemed defensive and was not open to my suggestions. To handle the situation, I remained calm and patient, and I made an effort to understand their perspective. I explained the reasons behind my feedback and emphasized the importance of accuracy and compliance with regulations. I also offered to assist them in making the necessary revisions. Eventually, the appraiser started to see the value in my feedback and agreed to make the changes. This experience taught me the importance of effective communication and being diplomatic in challenging situations.

A more solid answer

Yes, I have encountered a situation where an appraiser was not receptive to my feedback or guidance. It was during a review process for a complex appraisal report, and I observed several errors and omissions that needed to be addressed. I approached the appraiser in a respectful manner, acknowledging their expertise and highlighting the importance of accuracy in appraisal reports. I provided detailed explanations and examples to support my feedback, and I offered to collaborate with them to make the necessary revisions. Despite initially being defensive, the appraiser eventually recognized the value of my input and we worked together to produce a revised report that met compliance standards. This experience reinforced the significance of effective communication, patience, and collaboration in resolving conflicts and improving the quality of appraisal services.

Why this is a more solid answer:

The solid answer expands on the basic answer by providing more specific details about the situation encountered, such as it being a review process for a complex appraisal report with errors and omissions. The candidate demonstrates their approach by acknowledging the appraiser's expertise and highlighting the importance of accuracy. The candidate also offers collaboration and provides detailed explanations and examples to support their feedback. The answer clearly shows how the candidate handled the situation and resolves conflicts. However, the answer could still benefit from further elaboration and additional examples to make it exceptional.

An exceptional answer

Yes, I encountered a situation where an appraiser was not receptive to my feedback or guidance. In a high-stakes review process of a commercial property appraisal, I noticed several critical errors that could have had significant implications. Understanding the sensitive nature of the situation, I approached the appraiser with utmost professionalism and displayed empathy towards their perspective. I took the time to listen actively and validate their concerns, emphasizing that my intention was to uphold regulatory compliance and maintain the highest standards of appraisal quality. To address their defensiveness, I highlighted my own experience, mentioning situations where I had made mistakes and welcomed constructive criticism. With a collaborative mindset, I presented a detailed analysis of the errors, using market data and relevant industry guidelines to illustrate the necessity for revisions. Additionally, I shared success stories from past engagements to showcase the positive outcomes of incorporating feedback. By maintaining open lines of communication, fostering trust, and demonstrating genuine interest in mutual growth, I was able to transform their resistance into receptivity. Together, we successfully rectified the discrepancies and ultimately delivered a revised appraisal report that received appreciation from the client. This experience reinforced the importance of effective communication, patience, and empathy in navigating challenging situations.

Why this is an exceptional answer:

The exceptional answer goes beyond the solid answer by adding more specific details and examples to make the response more comprehensive and informative. The candidate describes the situation as a high-stakes review process of a commercial property appraisal with critical errors. They approach the appraiser with professionalism and empathy, actively listening and validating their concerns. The candidate highlights their own experience and uses market data and industry guidelines to support their feedback. They also share success stories to showcase the benefits of incorporating feedback. The answer emphasizes the importance of maintaining open communication, fostering trust, and displaying genuine interest in mutual growth. Overall, the exceptional answer demonstrates a thorough understanding of effective communication, patience, and empathy in navigating challenging situations.

How to prepare for this question

  • Familiarize yourself with industry regulations and compliance standards related to appraisals to effectively communicate their importance.
  • Prepare examples of challenging situations you have encountered in the past and how you handled them to showcase your interpersonal skills and effective communication.
  • Practice active listening and empathy to be better prepared for understanding the perspective of appraisers who may be resistant to feedback or guidance.
  • Highlight instances where your feedback or guidance has resulted in positive outcomes, ensuring to emphasize the value it brings to appraisal services.
  • Research and stay updated on the latest trends and advancements in the real estate market and valuation techniques to enhance your credibility and expertise.

What interviewers are evaluating

  • Interpersonal skills
  • Effective communication

Related Interview Questions

More questions for Appraisal Reviewer interviews