Tell me about a time when you had to compromise on a design decision. How did you handle it?
User Interface Designer Interview Questions
Sample answer to the question
One time, while working on a mobile app design, I had a strong vision for the layout and color scheme. However, the development team expressed concerns about the feasibility and performance of the design. After discussing the issue with them, I realized that some compromises needed to be made. I adjusted the layout to optimize performance and chose a color scheme that was still visually appealing, but also more lightweight. I communicated these changes to the team and explained the reasoning behind them. Ultimately, the compromise resulted in a more efficient and user-friendly design.
A more solid answer
One project I worked on involved designing a website for a client. The client had specific preferences for the color scheme and layout, but our development team had concerns about the performance of the design. After discussing the issue with both the client and the development team, I realized that a compromise was necessary. I proposed alternative color options that still aligned with the client's preferences but were more lightweight. Additionally, I adjusted the layout to improve performance while maintaining the overall look and feel of the design. I presented these changes to the client, explaining the reasoning behind them and showcasing how the compromise would result in a better user experience. The client appreciated our proactive approach and agreed to the compromise. As a result, we were able to deliver a website that met the client's expectations while also considering the technical constraints.
Why this is a more solid answer:
The solid answer provides more specific details about the project, the design decision, and the impact of the compromise on the final outcome. It also highlights the candidate's ability to communicate effectively and find a solution that considers both the client's preferences and the development team's concerns. The answer could be further improved by discussing any specific challenges faced during the process.
An exceptional answer
During my time working as a user interface designer, I encountered a situation where I had to compromise on a design decision for a mobile app. The project involved designing a messaging interface for a social media app. I had initially designed a complex and visually appealing layout with multiple animation effects. However, the development team raised concerns about the app's performance and the potential impact on user experience, especially on older devices. Recognizing the need for compromise, I collaborated with both the development team and the product manager to find a solution. After brainstorming and prototyping different options, we decided to simplify the layout and reduce the number of animation effects, while still maintaining the overall visual appeal. I also conducted usability testing to gather feedback from users and iterated on the design based on their input. The compromise resulted in a more efficient and user-friendly messaging interface that met both the design goals and technical requirements.
Why this is an exceptional answer:
The exceptional answer provides a detailed description of the project, the specific design decision, the collaboration with the development team and product manager, and the iterative process to gather user feedback. It showcases the candidate's ability to handle complex design challenges, collaborate effectively with cross-functional teams, and prioritize user experience. The answer effectively demonstrates the candidate's problem-solving, adaptability, and communication skills. It could be further improved by discussing the specific impact of the compromise on the app's performance and user satisfaction.
How to prepare for this question
- Reflect on past projects where you had to compromise on design decisions. Think about the specific details of the projects, the reasons for the compromises, and the outcomes.
- Consider the different stakeholders involved in the design process and how their feedback and concerns can influence design decisions.
- Practice explaining your design decisions and compromises in a clear and concise manner. Highlight the rationale behind your choices and how they contribute to the overall usability and user experience.
- Stay updated on current design trends and technologies to ensure a well-informed and adaptable approach to design.
- Develop your interpersonal and communication skills to effectively collaborate with cross-functional teams and address conflicting perspectives.
What interviewers are evaluating
- Problem-solving
- Adaptability
- Interpersonal and communication skills
Related Interview Questions
More questions for User Interface Designer interviews