/VP of Finance/ Interview Questions
INTERMEDIATE LEVEL

Tell me about a time when you had to evaluate a financial proposal or business case. How did you approach the evaluation process?

VP of Finance Interview Questions
Tell me about a time when you had to evaluate a financial proposal or business case. How did you approach the evaluation process?

Sample answer to the question

In my previous role as a Finance Manager at XYZ Company, I had to evaluate a financial proposal for a potential acquisition. I approached the evaluation process by first thoroughly reviewing the proposal and identifying key financial metrics such as net present value, return on investment, and payback period. I also analyzed the underlying assumptions and risks associated with the proposal. Next, I conducted a detailed financial analysis using advanced Excel models to project the potential financial impact of the acquisition. I also considered market trends and competitor analysis to assess the viability of the proposal. Throughout the evaluation process, I collaborated with cross-functional teams, including the operations and legal departments, to gather additional insights and ensure alignment with the overall business strategy. Ultimately, I presented my findings and recommendations to the senior management team, highlighting the financial benefits and potential risks of the proposal.

A more solid answer

In my previous role as a Finance Manager at XYZ Company, I had to evaluate a financial proposal for a potential acquisition. To approach the evaluation process, I first assembled a cross-functional team consisting of representatives from finance, operations, and legal departments to ensure a comprehensive assessment. As the team leader, I delegated tasks and set clear expectations for each member. I took charge of analyzing the financial aspects of the proposal by using financial software and advanced Excel models to create detailed projections and perform sensitivity analyses. Additionally, I conducted market research and competitor analysis to evaluate the proposal's strategic fit and potential risks. Throughout the evaluation process, I maintained open communication channels with team members, holding regular meetings to discuss progress, address any challenges, and gather input. I compiled all the findings into a comprehensive report, including a detailed financial analysis, risk assessment, and recommendations for senior management. This collaborative and data-driven approach resulted in the successful evaluation and subsequent approval of the financial proposal.

Why this is a more solid answer:

The solid answer provides more specific details and examples to demonstrate the candidate's skills in the evaluation areas mentioned in the job description, such as their leadership and people management skills in assembling a cross-functional team, delegating tasks, and maintaining open communication channels. The answer also highlights their proficiency in financial software and advanced Excel skills by mentioning the use of these tools for financial analysis. However, it could still be improved by providing more quantitative results or specific impacts of the financial proposal evaluation, as well as addressing how the candidate strategized and solved problems efficiently.

An exceptional answer

In my previous role as a Finance Manager at XYZ Company, I was tasked with evaluating a complex financial proposal for a potential joint venture with a global partner. Recognizing the significance of the decision, I took a strategic approach to the evaluation process. First, I conducted a thorough analysis of the industry landscape, studying market trends, competitive dynamics, and regulatory conditions to gauge the potential risks and opportunities. I then collaborated with the finance team to develop a comprehensive financial model using advanced Excel techniques and realistic assumptions. To assess the proposal's viability, I created multiple scenarios and performed sensitivity analyses to assess the potential financial outcomes under different market conditions. Furthermore, I organized cross-functional workshops to gather insights from key stakeholders and address any concerns or roadblocks. During these workshops, I facilitated productive discussions and utilized my exceptional communication skills to ensure alignment and obtain buy-in from all parties involved. The evaluation process required critical thinking and problem-solving skills as I encountered various challenges, such as conflicting priorities and complex contractual arrangements. However, I efficiently managed these challenges by prioritizing tasks and seeking input from subject matter experts when needed. The outcome of the evaluation process was a comprehensive report that included quantitative and qualitative analysis, risk assessment, and a well-reasoned recommendation that highlighted the financial benefits and long-term strategic value of the joint venture.

Why this is an exceptional answer:

The exceptional answer provides a more comprehensive and detailed account of the candidate's approach to evaluating a financial proposal. It demonstrates their strong analytical and critical thinking skills by mentioning the thorough analysis of the industry landscape and the creation of multiple scenarios and sensitivity analyses. The answer also highlights the candidate's exceptional leadership and people management skills by discussing their facilitation of cross-functional workshops and their use of exceptional communication skills to ensure alignment. Additionally, it addresses the candidate's ability to strategize and solve problems efficiently by mentioning their prioritization of tasks and seeking input from subject matter experts. The exceptional answer effectively addresses the evaluation areas mentioned in the job description and provides a well-rounded and persuasive response.

How to prepare for this question

  • Familiarize yourself with financial software and advanced Excel techniques to enhance your ability to conduct detailed financial analysis.
  • Develop strong critical thinking skills by practicing analyzing complex financial proposals and considering various factors such as market trends, competitive dynamics, and regulatory conditions.
  • Improve your leadership and people management skills by seeking opportunities to lead cross-functional teams or projects.
  • Enhance your communication and interpersonal abilities by actively participating in workshops, presentations, or group discussions.
  • Proactively seek opportunities to evaluate financial proposals or business cases in your current or future role to gain practical experience and enhance your problem-solving skills.

What interviewers are evaluating

  • Analytical and critical thinking skills
  • Leadership and people management skills
  • Communication and interpersonal abilities
  • Proficient in financial software and advanced Excel skills
  • Ability to strategize and solve problems efficiently

Related Interview Questions

More questions for VP of Finance interviews