Employment Law and Compliance

The Dos and Don'ts of Asking About Criminal History in Interviews

An expert guide on the appropriate way to inquire about criminal background during job interviews, while complying with employment laws.

The Dos and Don'ts of Asking About Criminal History in Interviews
Listen to this article

The journey of recruitment often encompasses a ground where the laws of the land interweave with the ethics and considerations of social justice. One of the most treacherous parts of this terrain is the question of how - and indeed if - employers should ask about criminal history during job interviews.

With shifts in public attitudes towards criminal justice reform, and legislative changes such as 'Ban the Box' laws, it's imperative for employers and recruiters to navigate these waters with care. The aim of this article is to lay out the dos and don'ts of inquiring about criminal history, ensuring that you remain compliant with employment laws while also respecting the dignity and futures of potential employees.

Firstly, let's address the legal context. In the United States, 'Ban the Box' legislation has been adopted by numerous states and municipalities. It prohibits employers from asking about criminal history on job applications. The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) also sets standards for employment screening, including criminal background checks, requiring advance notice and applicant consent. Additionally, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) has issued guidelines that caution against blanket policies that exclude all applicants with a criminal record, as this can have a disparate impact on certain protected groups.

Do:

  • Research and understand the laws and regulations in your jurisdiction.
  • Wait until the later stages of the hiring process to inquire about criminal history if it's relevant to the job.

Don't:

  • Have blanket policies that immediately disqualify applicants with a criminal record.
  • Violate applicants' rights under the FCRA by failing to provide notice and obtain consent before conducting a background check.

Ethical Considerations and Best Practices

When it comes to ethics, remembering that individuals with a criminal background are actively seeking a second chance is critical. It is also important for employers to weigh the nature of the crime against the responsibilities of the position.

Do:

  • Consider the context of the offense, such as the nature, seriousness, and relevance to the job.
  • Allow candidates to explain their criminal history in a face-to-face interview, giving them the opportunity to discuss the circumstances and how they've changed.

Don't:

  • Make assumptions or judgments about a person's character or job suitability based solely on their criminal record.
  • Dismiss the idea of hiring someone with a criminal history without a thorough evaluation of the individual and the relevancy to the job.

Asking the Question

The way questions about criminal history are asked matters almost as much as whether they are asked. Framing the question in non-discriminatory terms is crucial.

Do:

  • Use neutral language and ensure that any questions about criminal history are job-related and consistent with business necessity.

Don't:

  • Ask questions in a manner that might embarrass or put unnecessary pressure on the applicant. Aim to be respectful and non-judgmental.

Evaluating Criminal History in Hiring Decisions

If it is necessary to consider an applicant's criminal history, it's important to evaluate each case individually rather than applying a blanket rule.

Do:

  • Assess the risk related to the job and the individual's criminal history.
  • Consider the time elapsed since the offense and any rehabilitation efforts.

Don't:

  • Disregard mitigating circumstances or evidence of the applicant's rehabilitation.
  • Automatically exclude candidates for old or minor offenses that have no bearing on job responsibilities.

Training for Interviewers

Interviewers need to be trained in how to address and assess criminal history appropriately during job interviews.

Do:

  • Provide comprehensive training covering legal restrictions and the principles of fair chance hiring.

Don't:

  • Allow interviewers to improvise questions about criminal history without proper training or guidelines.

Conclusion

The challenge of whether, when, and how to ask about criminal history in job interviews is one that requires nuance and sensitivity. By following these dos and don'ts, recruiters and employers can both respect the rights of candidates and protect the needs of their organization. It's not just about legal compliance but about fair chance hiring practices that can enrich our workforce with diverse perspectives and unique talents. Our commitment to these principles is not just good ethics—it's good business.

As the landscape of employment law continues to evolve, staying informed, consulting with legal experts, and regularly reviewing your recruitment practices is essential to ensuring that your interview processes remain just, equitable, and lawful.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Are employers allowed to ask about criminal history in job interviews?

Employers are generally allowed to ask about criminal history in job interviews, but it's important to comply with laws and regulations that govern this practice. 'Ban the Box' legislation in some states prohibits asking about criminal history on job applications, so it's advisable to wait until later stages of the hiring process if necessary.

2. How should employers handle disclosing criminal history to applicants?

Employers should handle the disclosure of criminal history with sensitivity and respect. It's recommended to frame questions in a non-discriminatory manner, using neutral language and ensuring that the inquiries are job-related and consistent with business necessity.

3. Can employers automatically disqualify candidates based on their criminal history?

Employers should not have blanket policies that automatically disqualify candidates based on criminal history. Each case should be evaluated individually, considering factors such as the nature of the offense, its relevance to the job, time elapsed since the offense, and any rehabilitation efforts made by the applicant.

4. What training should interviewers receive regarding inquiring about criminal history?

Interviewers should receive comprehensive training on legal restrictions, fair chance hiring principles, and how to address and assess criminal history during job interviews. It's crucial to ensure that interviewers understand the nuances involved and approach the topic with professionalism and fairness.

5. How can employers ensure they are compliant with employment laws when asking about criminal history?

Employers can ensure compliance with employment laws by staying informed about the legal landscape, consulting with legal experts when needed, and regularly reviewing and updating their recruitment practices. By following the dos and don'ts outlined in this article, employers can create a fair and lawful interview process that respects the rights of candidates.

Further Resources

For further in-depth knowledge and guidance on navigating the complexities of inquiring about criminal history in job interviews, here are some valuable external resources:

  1. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC): The EEOC provides guidelines and resources on fair chance hiring practices and avoiding discrimination based on criminal history.
  2. Ban the Box Movement: Explore the Ban the Box movement's website for information on state-specific laws and best practices for removing criminal history questions from job applications.
  3. Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM): SHRM offers articles, webinars, and training programs on inclusive hiring practices, including considerations for criminal history inquiries.
  4. National Employment Law Project (NELP): NELP provides research and advocacy on criminal justice reform and fair chance employment policies, offering insights for employers.
  5. HR Dive: Stay updated on the latest news and trends in HR and employment law, including articles on best practices for handling criminal history inquiries in interviews.
  6. LegalZoom - Employment Background Checks: LegalZoom offers resources on employment background checks, including guidance on complying with FCRA regulations when conducting criminal history screenings.
  7. National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL): Visit the NCSL website for a comprehensive overview of state laws related to criminal history inquiries in the hiring process, including Ban the Box legislation.
  8. Workplace Fairness - Criminal Records in Employment: Workplace Fairness provides information on the rights of job seekers with criminal records and best practices for employers when considering criminal history.

These resources offer a wealth of information to help organizations and hiring professionals navigate the complexities of addressing criminal history in interviews while upholding fair and legal practices. Stay informed and continuously educate your team to ensure fair chance hiring for all candidates.

If you found this article helpful, please share it with your friends
Other Sections in our Learning Center